| POL355: Civil Liberties, Spring 2004 Brett E. Marston MWF 10:20 - 11:15, Mahar 202 Office Hours: M, Tu, W 1:00-2:30 (438 Mahar) |
This course emphasizes both the historical development of and contemporary controversies over freedoms of religion and speech, searches and seizures, privacy, property, terrorism and the criminal justice system. |
Assignments and Grade Distribution
Short paper (10%), Midterm exam (30%), Case Briefs (15%), Final exam or
final paper (35%)
Class participation (10%)
The midterm will consist of a moot court in which four students (volunteers) will argue a hypothetical civil liberties case. The rest of the class will sit as justices and issue opinions on the case. You may write a final paper instead of the final exam if you give me seven (7) short reaction papers to the readings in the second half of the course. A reaction paper will be graded as "approved" if you write at least two paragraphs and explore some aspect of the reading that you find particularly interesting, troubling, enraging, perceptive, etc. If you choose to write a final paper, I will give you topics to write on; you may modify my suggested topic after consulting with me. At some point in the semester, you must give me written briefs on two cases from the course. We will discuss this requirement in the first week of the course. Most of the required readings will be found in the O'Brien casebook, but several are available only on the web. I will provide links to the web readings. If you have trouble accessing the web readings, please let me know.
Expectations
Class Schedule (subject to adjustment and change as the course progresses)
| Wk.1, 1/26-1/30 |
(Dis)Establishment, from the "High Wall" to the "Lemon Test": O'Brien, 663-684, 690-706 (Everson, Engel v. Vitale, Abington v. Schempp) |
| Wk. 2, 2/2-2/6 |
O'Brien, 706-742 (Lemon, Wallace v. Jaffree, Lee v. Weisman, Zobrest, Kiryas Joel) |
| Wk. 3, 2/9-2/13 |
O'Brien, 742-785 (Rosenberger, Agostini, Mitchell v. Helms) President Bush, Speech, 4/11/2002 (web) ; SC Watch 92-104 (Zelman)-- Paper #1 Due in class Friday, 2/13. Note: Friday 2/13 is the last day to drop. |
| Wk. 4, 2/16-2/20 |
Free Exercise (1): O'Brien, 785-812 (Sherbert v. Verner, Wisconsin v. Yoder, Employment Division v. Smith) |
| Wk. 5, 2/23-2/27 |
Free Exercise (2): O'Brien 812-834 (Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye, Boerne v. Flores), RLUIPA cases, NY (Beckett Fund summaries; read three of the summaries) |
| Wk. 6, 3/1-3/5 |
Property, Takings, and Public Use: O'Brien, 286-9, Pennsylvania Coal v. Mahon (web), Berman v. Parker (web), Penn Central v. New York City (web), Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit (web); Roger Pilon, "Protecting Private Property Rights from Regulatory Takings" (web) Georgetown Environmental Law and Policy Institute Takings Statement (web) |
| Wk. 7, 3/8-3/12 |
Takings, (cont.): O'Brien, 290-96 (Midkiff, Nollan), Loretto v. Teleprompter Manhattan CATV Corp (web), SC Watch, 33-39 (Tahoe-Sierra) -- Midterm Assignment Handed out, Wednesday 3/10 |
| Wk. 8, 3/22-3/26 |
Obscenity and Pornography: O'Brien, 420-438 (Roth, Miller) Moot Court and Midterm Due, Wednesday 3/24 O'Brien, 438-444 (Paris Adult Theater v. Slaton) |
| Wk. 9, 3/29-4/2 |
Obscenity (cont.): O'Brien, 444-471 (New York v. Ferber, City of Erie v. Pap's A.M, NEA v. Finley), SC Watch 53-63 (Alameda Books, Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition) |
| Wk. 10, 4/5-4/9 |
Fighting Words, Offensive Speech, Hate Speech: O'Brien 471-487, 491-506 (Cohen v. California, FCC v. Pacifica, R.A.V., Wisconsin v. Mitchell); SC Watch 82-91 (Virginia v. Black) |
| Wk. 11, 4/12-4/16 |
Warrantless Searches: Terry stops, racial profiling, "hot pursuit" and the "war on drugs": O'Brien 849-876 (Terry v. Ohio, Sokolow, Illinois v. Wardlow, Bond v. U.S., Minnesota v. Dickerson); Kolb, "The New Face of Racial Profiling" (web) |
| Wk. 12, 4/19-4/23 |
Administrative Searches: O'Brien, 835-7, 910-935 (NTEU v. Von Raab, Venonia School District v. Acton, Ferguson v. Charleston) Final Day for Case Briefs: Friday, 4/23 |
| Wk. 13, 4/26-4/30 |
Surveillance and "Expectations of Privacy": O'Brien 935-965 (Olmstead, Katz, Ciraolo, Minnesota v.Carter, Kyllo), SC Watch 111-115 (Board of Education v. Earls) |
| Wk. 14, 5/3-5/7 |
The Courts and the "War on Terrorism": David Cole, "Enemy Aliens," SC Watch 6-8, 9, John Dean, "The U.S. Supreme Court and the Imperial Presidency", "Supreme Court Examines Security, Terror" (AP story), Hamdi v. Rumsfeld (web) Padilla v. Rumsfeld (web) |
| Final Exam | Monday, May 10, 10:30am - 12:30pm |